Why John Lennon’s “Imagine” Album Is Somewhat Hypocritical

via Victor Batista / Youtube

John Lennon’s iconic album, Imagine, is hailed for its utopian vision and the timeless ballad that shares its name. However, when taken as a whole, the album reveals a certain degree of hypocrisy.

At the heart of the album lies the eponymous track, “Imagine.” It advocates for a world without borders, possessions, and religion, calling for a global brotherhood. It’s a beautiful song that inspires listeners to strive for a better future. Similarly, the track “Jealous Guy” reflects on personal growth and redemption, presenting a theme of self-improvement.

However, the album takes an unexpected turn with the inclusion of “How Do You Sleep?” This diss track aimed at Paul McCartney contradicts the notion of universal brotherhood presented in “Imagine.” Lennon criticizes McCartney’s songwriting, derailing the album’s energy and unity.

While “How Do You Sleep?” is undeniably catchy and humorous in its critique, it would have been better suited for an earlier album in Lennon’s solo career. The album that could have accommodated such a track is John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band, where he expressed grievances against various aspects of society, including his father, religion, and capitalism.

Despite these contradictions, Imagine enjoyed immense success on the pop charts. It reached the top spot on the Billboard 200, remaining on the chart for an impressive 47 weeks. In the United Kingdom, it also claimed the number one position for two weeks and spent a total of 101 weeks on the chart.

While John Lennon’s Imagine album contains timeless classics and resonates with audiences, its cohesiveness is compromised by the inclusion of “How Do You Sleep?” This track, although deserving in its own right, deviates from the album’s utopian theme. Nevertheless, Imagine’s popularity and impact remain undeniable, cementing its place in music history.